Was odysseus justified in killing the suitors. The Odyssey 2011: Is the Slaughter Justified? 2019-02-01

Was odysseus justified in killing the suitors Rating: 7,8/10 475 reviews

The Odyssey: Is Odysseus justified in taking his revenge?

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

Was it justified for him to do this? Athena's shield appears in the hall, inspiring further dread in the suitors. When Odysseus returns home, many of the arrogant suitors insult him and try to hurt him, thinking he is a beggar. In conclusion, Odysseus is guilty. I will include a sample based on Book 9 of The Odyssey soon. The suitor Amphimedon explains their fate to Agamemnon, who invidiously compares his deceitful, murderous wife Klytaimnestra to the faithful steadfastness of Penelope. He embodies the ideals Homeric Greeks aspired to: manly valor, loyalty, piety, and intelligence. He desperately wants to remove them from the home, but does not have the will power or fighting experience to take down all of the men.

Next

Book 22: What do you think of Odysseus killing the suitors? What do you think of his killing of those who embraced his knees and begged for mercy?

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

Telemachus and the others set up a fake wedding celebration. Against the skillful Odysseus, the suitors seem to stand little chance. Some suitors do beg for mercy pleading more innocent than the other suitors. Moreover, the father-son reunion between Odysseus and Telemachus and the latter's maturation through battle is given a twist here - Odysseus reunites with his own father again under a false identity at first, yet another motif , and it is Laertes who proves himself in a fight. Odysseus orders the room to be purified with fire and brimstone, and weeps as all his loyal servants embrace him.

Next

The Odyssey: Is Odysseus justified in taking his revenge?

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

They become just as guilty as their adversary. Revenge cannot be morally justified for the motives of guilt, pain, and the never ending thirst for vengeance. Even though some suitors were significantly crueler than others, I still felt that all of them should have been punished equally. They try to flee, then attempt to get … Odysseus away from the door so that they can escape. He was justified because those 100 suitors were taking over his city and attempting to marry his wife. In the epic poem, Odyssey by Homer, suitors do not deserved to die.


Next

Question wk of 12/6

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

Even though some suitors have been crueler than others, why does Odysseus take equal revenge on all of them? The modern reader could perhaps judge these references to money in relation to marriage as. Some of the suitors were harsher than others, but yet he punished them all the same. The way Shakespeare uses plot, characterization, and conflict to reveal the theme, is ingenious. In the Odyssey when Odysseus slaughtered all of the suitors with revenge, even though it was a chaotic outrage of a massacre I believe all of the suitors, maids, and traitors deserved it. Odysseus, though showing no mercy to the two suitors who beg at his knees or to the disloyal women of the house, does forgive his minstrel and herald.

Next

Essay on The Suitors Demise and Odysseus’s Revenge: Justified?

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

The tidy resolution underscores a final theme: the power of the gods. Since no one tried to stop the others, no one should be spared. In my opinion, that would be the typical thing to do. Odysseus hears him out, but says that, as a priest, he must have prayed for Odysseus to not come home, so he kills him anyway. He performed the feat of stringing his boy which no one other than his son Telemachus was able to do. They embrace and join the others inside to eat, including the old servant Dolius, father of the treacherous Melantho and Melanthius.

Next

The Odyssey Books 21

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

But what really is revenge? Some Antinous were crueler than others. The fact that Odysseus kills them all is not justified. GradeSaver, 23 July 2015 Web. Also, the suitors had previously received a prophecy that Odysseus would come back, and they knew that if they were there, they would be killed. Many men want to take over the palace, especially Antinous. It reminds me of a lesson I had in social studies, about the Code of Hammurabi. Honour killing is an ancient ritual in a modern world.

Next

The character of The Suitors in The Penelopiad from LitCharts

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

Instead of killing them, I think Odysseus should of just put them in prison for life. Additionally, Odysseus does not have the right to senselessly slaughter the suitors who decide against warfare and instead beg for mercy. You forrced yourselves upon this house. The motivation of revenge is vengeance. Although how he did so was not the best way to treat a person, what they did was wrong and still deserved it. Once the bed clears the air of any suspicions, Homer writes a beautiful emotional payoff of the couple's reunion with elegant and meaningful simile-filled language: Now from his breast into his eyes the ache of longing mounted, and he wept at last, his dear wife, clear and faithful, in his arms, longed for as the sunwarmed earth is longed for by a swimmer spent in rough water where his ship went down under Poseidon's blows, gale winds and tons of sea. If the suitors had not been killed, they would have come back to challenge Odysseus later and possibly kill him, like they were planning to do to Telemachus.


Next

Book 22: What do you think of Odysseus killing the suitors? What do you think of his killing of those who embraced his knees and begged for mercy?

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

Hector killed Achilles best friend and has to pay for his actions therefore Achilles has a right to be angry and seek justice. Odysseus is telling all the suitors that they thought he would never make it home from Troy. No one has been able to remove these uncontrollable suitors from the palace while Odysseus is not present. One suitor, Leodes, supplicates himself at Odysseus' knees, excusing himself from the others' actions. Not only that, but they are suitors because they are trying to court his wife while he is still alive. And, at last, Odysseus wreaks his revenge.

Next

The Odyssey 2011: Is the Slaughter Justified?

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

I think that Odysseus needed to do what he had to do to get all the suitors out and to not bother Penelope anymore. So the Suitors are not legible for the punishment of death for only showing bad Xenia. Odysseus weeps and holds his wife. After all Odysseus has been through, I would be insulted if the men who for years occupied my house, fought for my wife, and ate my food asked for mercy. The men eat his food, drink his wine, and try to steal his wife. Odysseus takes his revenge by killing each and every one of the suitors. Odysseus had every right to dispose of the suitors as he wished.

Next

Question wk of 12/6

was odysseus justified in killing the suitors

The suitors didnt even do anything that bad. Sure, they were disloyal, but it was better that they were sleeping with the suitors than his wife; Odysseus should have been thankful for that, or understanding at least. But, there is another kind of evil which we must fear most … and that is the indifference of good men! Everyone has the right to live, and once someone decides to kill another individual then they should lose that right. Some might serve as a faithful servant of Odysseus by learning from the death of Antinous. When you do something that hurts someone else you should have to pay for it. If they were not killed, Telemachus most definitely would have died because the suitors were plotting to kill him. Using these words Odysseus says that the suitors deserve to get murdered or slaughtered in the halls because of their actions.

Next